how to exorcise laplace's demon

Laplace was worried this sort of thing might happen and drive mere mortals insane...

laplace's demon comic snippet

From a comic by Aaron Diaz

For those of you who might not know, mathematician and astronomer Pierre-Simon Laplace proposed a little thought experiment about quantum physics long before Heisenberg was even born. Imagine knowing where everything in the universe is located and understand all the fundamental forces of nature.

If you had the kind of intellect capable of processing this data, you should technically be able to know everything that will happen in the future, everything that went on in the past and essentially becoming omniscient. Or, according to a comic by cartoonist Aaron Diaz, you would be rendered completely mad and require an urgent pseudo-exorcism…

Funny thing is that the idea of calling Laplace's hypothetical intellect demonic came long after he died, maybe because biographers and thinkers who considered his thought experiment didn't like the idea of a real life omniscience. With what we know today about quantum mechanics, it seems that it would be impossible for anyone or anything to have the kind of knowledge Laplace proposed since it its most fundamental level, there needs to be an element of chance even if we seem to have several physical laws about causality.

The key to this experiment is the differentiation between causality and determinism. Laplace thought the two were pretty much one and the same. In reality, determinism indicates a plan while causality doesn't need one.

  archived from wowt
              
# science // causality / determinism / entertainment / thought experiment


  show comments
latest reads

the xenonite plot armor of project hail mary

Hail Mary was a badly mismanaged, rushed death trap driven by groupthink and politics, and Ryland Grace was right to balk at the idea.
the xenonite plot armor of project hail mary

how ai can love bomb you into being an asshole

In ads, chatbots are omniscient arbiters and truth brokers. In practice, they're sycophantic enablers according to the latest research.
how ai can love bomb you into being an asshole

why we're all getting meaner and meaner online

Yes, being a professional asshole is now a viable career option. Which is awful news for online discourse.
why we're all getting meaner and meaner online

how and why corporate jargon and technobabble lull the mind

Yes, sadly, some of the worst stereotypes about corporate culture really are true.
how and why corporate jargon and technobabble lull the mind

the great theoretical chatbot job apocalypse

According to Anthropic, LLMs can obliterate most white collar jobs. Well, theoretically...
the great theoretical chatbot job apocalypse

i prompt, therefore i am: how tech forgot about human agency

Tone deaf tech bros no longer seem to understand that their pitch for AI is fundamentally dystopian and dismissive.
i prompt, therefore i am: how tech forgot about human agency